martechoutlookapac

A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by our MarTech Outlook Advisory Board.

Current Home

AI Can Build the Ad but it Can’t Shake the Hand

Tony Rodriguez

Marketing Trust Advocate

Tony Rodriguez is VP of Business Development at Current Home and an award-winning podcast host with 25+ years in sales, marketing and leadership. He runs the brand's AI-driven ad-production pipeline and co-hosts the award-winning show "Advice Unfiltered with Chris and Tony.

Seven years before this person recruited me, I gave up my dinner reservation to a stranger.

A couple walked in with their elderly parents, clearly celebrating something, facing an hour wait with no table. The older folks couldn’t stand that long, so I gave them mine and waited the extra hour—simply because it was the right thing to do. Afterward, the couple thanked me. We talked a few minutes, exchanged numbers, mentioned we both worked in marketing, and left it there.

Seven years later, that person was a senior vice president at Macy’s and recruited me to New York for a marketing executive role overseeing the home division in Manhattan. A small kindness I’d long forgotten became the hinge on which an entire chapter of my career swung.

In more than 25 years in this business, that story isn’t an outlier. It’s the pattern. The opportunities that changed my life rarely came from a campaign or a perfectly optimized funnel. They came from how I treated people when there was nothing in it for me.

“You can automate the path to the door. You can’t automate what happens once you’re inside it. Trust is built face to face.”

Here’s another. For years I was a regular at Lifetime Fitness, and I made a point of being decent to everyone there—no agenda. One day the head trainer asked me to host a podcast. I said yes. That show is now the number one podcast in the world for self-help and self-improvement, and for relationship and dating advice. A relationship I never tried to monetize became the most valuable door I’ve ever walked through.

I’m not against technology. I run an AI production pipeline every day—generating video, building ad creative and managing budgets faster than I could a decade ago. The tools are incredible: better data, more speed, ideas brought to life faster than ever.

But here’s what I keep coming back to. AI is a brilliant accumulation of nearly all the knowledge on the internet. What it can’t do is feel what’s happening in a room in real time. People’s emotions and attitudes change by the second, and a lot of that data can only be read—and entered—by a person who’s actually there. AI doesn’t catch the hesitation in someone’s voice. It doesn’t know when to stop talking. It doesn’t sense the moment trust tips into yes.

In my own work, the line is clear. AI can build the ad. It can run the budget. It can generate the lead. What it cannot do is close the sale. Closing a deal—anything from a few hundred dollars to a few hundred thousand—still comes down to showing up, looking someone in the eye and shaking their hand. You can automate the path to the door. You can’t automate what happens once you’re inside it. Trust is built face to face.

This is where organizations lose the plot. They fixate on the dashboard and forget what every number represents. But every click and conversion is a real person making a real decision.

So, the question everyone’s asking: is AI going to replace you? It may replace a lot of things—the mundane work, the data entry, the searches that now take seconds. That’s fine. That’s what technology has always done: absorb the repetitive parts and free people up for the work that requires a human.

But replace people? That’s a different claim entirely.

Call it nostalgia if you want—but nostalgia exists for a reason. We’re built to reach for the stars, and we finally have the information to get there. And yet we’re still human. We want to hold someone’s hand, look them in the face, tell them we love them. You might think that has nothing to do with getting ahead. It has everything to do with it.

Picture two people who are dead even—same tools, same data, same AI aptitude. What separates them? Who do I trust? Who shows up? Who brings a great attitude when things get hard? You can’t teach a machine that, and you can’t always teach a person it either. That’s the edge, and it’s a human one.

That’s the future I’d bet on: not AI replacing people, but the best communicators, leaders and marketers adding AI on top of their workflow. The tool amplifies the human. It was never meant to become the human.

So lean in. Use everything. Let the machines take the mundane and give you back your time. Just don’t mistake the tools for the point: they bring your ideas to life faster, but the relationships are why anyone says yes.

Platforms will change, algorithms will evolve and a year from now my own pipeline will look quaint. But the law of business holds: people trust people. So be kind to the stranger across the table. You never know who they’ll turn out to be in seven years.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.

Weekly Brief